Overeating at Easter? Don’t Feel Guilty — Here’s a Better Way to Think About Food

Easter is a time for family, celebration, and of course—chocolate. While it’s a joyful season, it can also trigger feelings of guilt or shame around food, particularly for those on a weight loss journey or recovering from bariatric surgery.

At Tonic Weight Loss Surgery, we want to remind you that one weekend does not define your success. Overeating during the holidays is common—and entirely human. What matters most is how you respond afterwards.

This Easter, we’re encouraging a new perspective on food, balance, and self-kindness, with expert guidance from our psychotherapist, Rebecca Smith.

Why Easter Can Feel Emotionally Overwhelming

For many people, food is deeply tied to emotion. Easter traditions often include large family meals, sweet treats, and social pressure to indulge—making it difficult to stick to structured eating plans. If you’ve undergone weight loss surgery, this time can bring up questions like:

“What if I eat too much?”
“Have I undone my progress?”
“Why do I feel guilty after enjoying food?”

The answer lies in reframing your relationship with food, not restricting it.

BMI Calculator

Use our BMI calculator below to find out if your weight is healthy.

Metric Imperial

Weight

Height

A BMI of 18.5 to 24.9 kg/m2 is described as within a ‘healthy’ weight range.

Your BMI is less than 18.5, you are underweight for your height.

A BMI of 30 kg/m2 and above is described as within an ‘obese’ weight range.

Your BMI is over 40, you are in the obese category

Your BMI score is 23.4

Make an appointment

Guilt Doesn’t Belong at the Table

It’s important to understand that overeating now and then is normal. Whether you’ve had a gastric sleeve, gastric bypass, or are early in your weight loss journey, no one eats perfectly all the time.

Rebecca Smith, our psychotherapist at Tonic, often reminds patients that guilt has no nutritional value. In fact, guilt and shame around eating can lead to:

Binge-restrict cycles
Negative body image
Increased emotional eating
Delayed recovery after setbacks

Instead, she encourages patients to take a compassionate, realistic approach: acknowledge it, learn from it, and move forward.

The Psychology of Food and Control

After weight loss surgery, you may have more control over your physical hunger, but emotional hunger can still be a challenge. That’s why our aftercare programme includes psychotherapy sessions with Rebecca, helping patients:

Understand the root of emotional eating
Develop tools to manage triggers
Build a healthier relationship with food and self-image

Holidays can bring up feelings of nostalgia, stress, or even loneliness—leading to emotional eating. Rebecca works with patients to identify these emotions and respond with self-awareness rather than self-criticism.

How to Get Back on Track After Overeating

If you feel like you overindulged this Easter, here are some practical steps to help you reset without guilt:

Avoid Restrictive “Make-Up” Diets  Skipping meals or punishing yourself won’t help. Return to your usual eating habits and routine.
Hydrate and Nourish Your Body  Drink water, eat protein-rich meals, and add fibre-filled vegetables to support digestion and energy.
Reflect, Don’t Criticise  Ask yourself what triggered the overeating. Were you bored, stressed, or just celebrating? Reflection builds awareness.
Use Your Support Network  Reach out to your Tonic psychotherapist or support group. You’re not alone, and sharing your experience can be empowering.
Refocus on Long-Term Habits  Weight loss isn’t defined by a single weekend—it’s about the overall lifestyle changes you commit to over time.

Self-Kindness Is Part of the Process

At Tonic, we believe that mental wellbeing is just as important as physical health. That’s why we offer unlimited access to our psychotherapist, Rebecca Smith, for two years after surgery.

Her patient-centred approach empowers individuals to:

Let go of food guilt
Develop mindful eating habits
Create healthy coping mechanisms
Build confidence and emotional resilience

Jessica success story from tonic weight loss surgery

A Healthier Mindset for a Healthier Life

Weight loss surgery is a powerful tool, but long-term success also comes from the way you think, feel, and care for yourself. This Easter, allow yourself grace. You are not failing—you are learning.

Let every meal, celebration, and slip-up be an opportunity to grow—not a reason to shame yourself.

Start Your Journey with the Right Support

If you’re considering weight loss surgery or need support following your procedure, we’re here to help you thrive—body and mind. Our comprehensive aftercare includes nutrition, fitness, and mental health support to guide you every step of the way.

Take the first step toward lifelong change with expert surgical care and the support of our full aftercare team, including dietitians, fitness coaches, and psychotherapist Rebecca Smith.

Related blogs

Looking for some further reading? We’ve got you covered – check out our selection of blogs!

Covering everything from bariatric surgery to general weight loss tips and tricks, there’s something for everyone here.

See all blogs